The measurement of ‘fiscal burden’ on GDP instead than on national net value added produced: a chapter in fiscal illusion
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.13133/2037-3643/10582Keywords:
GDP, National Net Value Added Produced, Tax burden, Public economyAbstract
The work calls attention to a major macroeconomic fiscal illusion: that arising from the current official practice of expressing the main fiscal indicators, and particularly the tax burden, as a percentage of GDP rather than NDPF (Net Domestic Product at Factor Costs). This methodology causes a systematic undervaluation of the tax burden, by something between 25% (Sweden and Austria) and 15% (Switzerland). Correctly measured, the tax burden in most European countries is above 50% and in the Nordic countries above 65%, or close to it! Thus, tax payers are deceived about the true cost and size of the public economy. GDP’s origin and widespread adoption is examined as well as the development of the notion of national income adopted to assess the tax burden.
JEL Codes: H20, H21
References
BAKER, S.H. (1983), "The determinants of medium voter tax liability. An empirical test of tax illusion hypotesis", Public Finance Quarterly, 11, pp. 95-108.
BERGSTROM, T.C. and R.P. GOODMAN (1973), "Private demands for public goods", American Economic Review, 63, pp. 280-96.
BOLDRINI, M. (1925), "Capacità contributiva e gravame in alcuni stati", Metron, vol. V, no. 3.
BOLDRINI, M. (1929), "Il reddito privato in alcuni stati nel 1927-28", Il Commercio, 9.
BORGATTA, G. (1929), Appunti di scienza delle finanze e diritto finanziario, Milano, Tipografia Mariani.
BORGATTA, G., a cura di (1934), Prefazione in Finanza, vol. IX, Nuova collana degli economisti, Utet, Torino.
BOWLEY, A. (1922), "The definition of national income", Economic Journal, vol. XXXII, pp. 1-11.
BOWLEY, A. and J. STAMP (1927), The National Income 1924, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
BREEDEN, H. and W.J. HUNTER (1985),"Tax revenue and tax structure", Public Finance Quarterly, 13, pp. 216-24.
BUCHANAN, J. (1967), Public Finance in a Democratic Process, University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill.
CLARK, C. (1937), National Income and Outlay, Macmillan, London.
CLARK, C. (1937), "National income and its climax", Economic Journal, vol. XLVII, pp. 308-20.
CLARK, C. (1938), "Determination of the multiplier from the national income statistics", Economic Journal, vol. XLVIII, pp. 435-48.
COLM, G. (1936), "Theory of public expenditure", Annals of Academy of Political and Social Sciences, pp. 1-11.
COLM, G. (1955), "Theory of public expenditure", Essays in Public Finance and Fiscal Policy, Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 27-43.
COLM, G. (1937), "Public revenue and public expenditure in national income", in Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research, pp. 175-248.
COLM, G. (1950), "Public finance in the national income", Bulletin of Central Bank of Venezuela, nos 59-60, January-February, pp. 17-26.
COLM, G. (1955), "Public finance in the national income", Essays in Public Finance and Fiscal Policy, Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 223-40.
COLM, G. (1951), "Experience in the use of social accounting in public policy in the United States", in E. Lundberg, ed., Income and Wealth, Series I, International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, pp. 75-99, Bowes and Bowes, Cambridge.
COLSON, C. (1918-31), Cours d'Economie Politique, Livre III, Paris, Gauthier Villars.
COMPETITIVENESS ADVISORY GROUP (1995), Enhancing European Competitiveness, First Report to the President of the Commission, the Prime Ministers and Heads of State, Commission of the European Communities, Bruxelles.
COPELAND, M.A. (1937), "Concepts of national income", in Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research, pp. 3-34.
D'ALBERGO, E. (1952), Economia della finanza pubblica, vol. II, ch. XV, Steb, Bologna.
DE VERGOTTINI, M. (1950), "Sul carico tributario reale", in Finanza pubblica contemporanea. Studi in onore di J. Tivaroni, Laterza, Bari, pp. 139-43.
DE VITI DE MARCO, A. (1928), Primi principi di economia finanziaria, Sanpaolesi, Roma.
DE VITI DE MARCO, A. (1934), Principi di economia finanziaria, ch. XV, Einaudi, Torino.
DE VITI DE MARCO, A. (1936), First Principles of Public Finance, Harcourt Brace, New York (translation of De Viti De Marco, 1928).
DOLLERY, B.E. and A.C. WORTHINGTON (1996), "The empirical analysis of fiscal illusion", Journal of Economic Surveys, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 262-95.
EDEY, A.C. and A.T. PEACOCK (1954), National Income and Social Accounting, Hutchinson's University Library, London.
EINAUDI, L. (1929), "Del cosidetto prelievo dell'imposta e dei suoi effetti sulla valutazione del reddito e della ricchezza di un paese", Riforma Sociale, vol. XL, pp. 225-38.
FASIANI, M. (1951), Principi di Scienze delle Finanze, vol. I, Libro I, Giappichelli, Torino.
FORTE, F. and J. BUCHANAN (1961), "The valuation of public services", Journal of Political Economy, vol. LXIX, no. 2, April, pp. 107-21.
FRIEDMAN, M. (1937), "Comment" to Copeland (1937), in Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research.
FRISCH, R. (1945), "Attempt at clarification of certain Income Concepts", University Institute of Economics, Oslo, mimeo
GILBERT, M. and G. JASZI (1944), "National product and income statistics as an aid in economic problems", Duns Review.
GILBERT, M. and G. JASZI (1944), "National product and income statistics as an aid in economic problems", W. Fellner and B.F. Haley, eds, Readings in the Theory of Income Distribution, selected for the American Economic Association, Allen & Unwin, London.
GINI, C. (1925), A comparison of the Wealth and National Income of Several Important Nations before and after the War, Libreria dello Stato, Roma.
GRAIG, E.D. and A.J. HEIMS (1980), "The effect of tax elasticity on public spending", Public Choice, 35, pp. 267-75.
GRIZIOTTI, B. (1940), Primi elementi di scienza delle finanze, ch. IV, Principato, Milano.
GRIZIOTTI, B. (1952), "Considerazioni metodologiche sul calcolo della pressione finanziaria", Giornale degli Economisti, nov.-dic., pp. 710-26.
GRIZIOTTI, B. (1953), "Considerazioni metodologiche sul calcolo della pressione finanziaria", Saggi sul rinnovamento dello studio della scienza delle finanze e del diritto finanziario, pp. 263-80, Giuffrè, Milano.
HEYNDELS, B. and C. SMOLDERS (1994), "Fiscal illusion at the local level. Empirical evidence for the Flenish municipalities", Public Choice, 80, pp. 325-38.
HICKS, J.R. (1940), "On the valuation of social income", Economica, VII, pp. 105-24.
HOLZ, W. (1924), "Sind internationale Vergleiche steuerlicher Belastungen in B. Moll, Probleme der Geld- und Finanzwesen, Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig.
HUNTER, W.J. and C.E. SCOTT (1987), "Statutory changes in state income taxes, an indirect test of fiscal illusion", Public Choice, 53, pp. 41-51.
KEYNES, J.M. (1936), General Theory of Income and Employment, Macmillan, London.
KEYNES, J.M. (1940), "The concept of national income. A supplementary note", Economic Journal, March, pp. 626-34.
KEYNES, J.M. (1978), "The concept of national income. A supplementary note", The Collected Writings, vol. XII, Activities 1939-45, London, Macmillan.
KUTZNETS, S. (1933), "National income", Encyclopedia of Social Sciences, vol. XI.
KUTZNETS, S. (1950), "National income", W. Fellner and B. Haley eds, Readings in the Theory of Income Distri-bution, Allen & Unwin, London.
KUTZNETS, S. (1934), "National income 1929-32", Bulletin, 49, National Bureau of Economic Research, New York.
KUTZNETS, S. (1934), "Gross capital formation, 1929-33", Bulletin, 52, National Bureau of Economic Research, New York.
KUTZNETS, S. (1936), National Income in the United States, 1929-1935, Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce, Washington.
KUTZNETS, S. (1937), "Changing inventory valuations and their effect on business savings and on national income produced", in Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research, New York.
KUTZNETS, S. (1937), Discussion of Copeland, in Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research.
KUTZNETS, S. (1937), Discussion of Colm, in Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research.
KUTZNETS, S. (1951), "Government product and national income", in E. Lundberg ed., Income and Wealth, Series I, International Association in Income and Wealth, Bowes and Bowes, Cambridge.
LANDAU, D. (1983), "Government expenditure and economic growth. Across country study", Southern Economic Journal, 49, pp. 783-92.
LEROY BEAULIEU, P. (1876), Traité de la Science des Finances, Guillaumin & Co., Paris.
MARLOW, M.L. (1986), "Private sector shrinkage and the growth of industrialized economies", Public Choice, 49, pp. 143-54.
MARSHALL, A. (1920), Principles of Economics, eighth ed., Book VI, ch. I, Macmillan, London.
MARTIN R. and M. FARDMANESH (1990), "Fiscal variables and growth: across sectorial analysis", Public Choice, 64, pp. 239-51.
MARTINEZ VAZQUEZ, J. (1983), "Renters illusion or savvy?", Public Finance Quarterly, 11, pp. 237-43.
MCCULLOCH, J.R. (1845), A Treatise on the Practical Influence of Taxation and the Funding Systems.
MCCULLOCH, J.R. (1975), A Treatise on the Practical Influence of Taxation and the Funding Systems, D.P. O'Brien ed., Scottish Academic Press, Edin-burgh.
MISOLEK, W. and H.W. ELDER (1988), "Tax structure and the size of Government. An empirical analysis of the fiscal illusion and fiscal stress arguments", Public Choice, 57, pp. 233-45.
MITHOFF, T. and G. SCHONBERG (1898), "Die Volkswirtschaftliche Verteilung" in G. Schonberg, hrsg. von, Handbuch der Volkswirtschaft, I Band, II Teil.
MORTARA, C. (1924), Prospettive economiche, Società Tipografica Leonardo da Vinci, Città di Castello.
MORTARA, C. (1925), Prospettive economiche, Società Tipografica Leonardo da Vinci, Città di Castello.
MORTARA, C. (1932), Prospettive economiche, dodicesima edizione, Università Bocconi, Milano.
MORTARA, C. (1934), Prospettive economiche, quattordicesima edizione, Università Bocconi, Milano.
NELSON, M.A. (1986), "Voters perception of the cost of Government. The case of local school expenditure in Louisiana", Public Finance Quarterly, 14, pp. 48-68.
NITTI, F.S. (1903), Scienza delle finanze, Pierro, Napoli.
NITTI, F.S. (1972), Scienza delle finanze, F. Forte, Bari, Laterza.
OATES, W.E. (1975), "Automatic increase in tax revenues. The effect of the size of public budget", in Financing the New Federation. Revenue Sharing Conditional Grants and Taxation, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
PANTALEONI, G. (1887), "Teoria della pressione tributaria".
PANTALEONI, G. (1938), "Teoria della pressione tributaria", Studi di finanza e statistica, Bologna, Zanichelli, pp. 45-108.
PEDEN, E. and M.D. BRADLEY (1988), "Government size, productivity and economic growth: the post war experience", Public Choice, 61, pp. 229-45.
PIETRA G, and G. FERRARI (1935), "Ricchezza e reddito delle nazioni", in C. Gini ed, Trattato elementare di statistica, vol. IV, Giuffre, Milano.
PIGOU, A.C. (1920-32), The Economics of Welfare, Macmillan, fourth edition, ch. HI, London.
POMMERHENE, W.W. and F. SCHNEIDER (1978), "Fiscal illusion, political institutions and local spending", Kyklos, 31, pp. 381-408.
PUVIANI, A. (1903), Teoria dell'illusione finanziaria.
PUVIANI, A. (1973), Teoria dell'illusione finanziaria, F. Volpi, Isedi, Milano.
RAM, R. (1986), "Government size and economic growth. A new framework and some evidence from cross-section and time series data", American Economic Review, 76, pp. 191-203.
RICCA SALERNO, P. (1943), "Sul concetto di pressione tributaria", in Studi in memoria di G. Masci, vol. II, Giuffrè, Milano, pp. 287-304.
RICCI, U. (1937), "La pression fiscale", Revue d'Economie Politique, Mars-Avril. RODBERTUS (1884), Das Kapital, Theofil Kosak, Berlin.
RUGGLES, R. (1949), National Income Accounts and Income Analysis, Mc Graw Hill, New York.
RUGGLES, R. and N. RUGGLES (1956), National Income Accounts and Income Analysis, McGraw Hill, New York.
SCULLY, G. (1989), "The size of the state, economic growth and efficient utilization of national resources", Public Choice, 33, pp. 149-64.
SELIGMAN, E. (1925), "Comparative tax burdens in the twentieth century", in Studies in Public Finance, Macmillan, London.
SELIGMAN, E. (1959), "Comparative tax burdens in the twentieth century", Kelley, New York.
SENSINI, G. (1917), "Prime linee di finanza teorica", in Scritti vari in onore di Tullio Martello, Laterza, Bari.
SHIRRAS, G.F. (1925), "Taxable capacity and burden of taxation and public debt", Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, vol. XXXVIII, part IV.
SHIRRAS, G.F. and G.F. ROSTAS (1943), The Burden of British Taxation, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
SMART, G. (1899), The Distribution of Income, Macmillan, Glasgow.
SOCIETE DES NATIONS (1929), "Memorandum sur les Finances Publiques, 1922-1928", Genève.
STATISTIQUE GENERALE DE LA FRANCE (1930), Bulletin, July-September.
STAMP, J. (1920), Wealth and Taxable Capacity, Macmillan, London.
STAMP, J. (1934), "Methods used in different countries for estimating national income", Journal of the Royal Statistical Society.
STAMP, J. (1937), "Methods used in different countries for estimating national income", The National Capital and Other Statistical Studies, King & Son, London.
STONE, R. (1951), "Functions and criteria of a system of social accounting", in E. Lundberg ed., Income and Wealth, Series I, International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Bowes and Bowes, Cambridge.
TANGORRA, V. (1922), "La pressione fiscale in Italia", Rivista internazionale, vol. XCIII, pp. 209-16.
TANZI, V. (1986), Inflazione e imposta personale sul reddito. Una prospettiva internazionale, il Mulino, Bologna.
TIVARONI, J. (1935), "La pressione tributaria in Italia attraverso il tempo", in C. Gini, a cura di, Trattato elementare di statistica, vol. IV, Giuffrè, Milano.
VINCI, F. (1945), Gli ordinamenti economici, vol. I, Milano, Giuffrè.
VINCI, F. (1946), "Sul concetto di pressione fiscale", Rivista Bancaria, 12, pp. 8-13.
VINCI, F. (1950), Istituzioni di economia, Zuffi, Bologna.
WAGNER, A. (1876 e 1892), Grundlegung der politischen Okonomie, Winter, Leipzig.
WAGNER, R.E. (1976), "Revenue structure, fiscal illusion and budgetary choices", Public Choice, 25, pp. 45-61.
WARBURTON, C. (1934), "Value of the Gross National Product and of its components, 1919-1929", Journal of the American Statistical Association, December.
WARBURTON, C. (1937), "Accounting methodology in the measurement of national income", in Studies on Income and Wealth, vol. I, National Bureau of Economic Research, New York.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
