Secular stagnation or stagnation policy? Steindl after Summers

Authors

  • Eckhard Hein Berlin School of Economics and Law Badensche Str. 52 10825 Berlin

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.13133/2037-3643_69.276_1

Keywords:

secular stagnation, stagnation policy, distribution and growth, Steindl

Abstract

The debate on secular stagnation suffers from vagueness and several shortcomings, which affect its economic policy implications. In this work we provide an alternative view on the advanced economies’ tendencies to stagnation, based on Josef Steindl’s contributions. Steindl’s pioneering 1952 book in particular is not prone to several problems that affect the current debate on secular stagnation. It does not rely on the dubious notion of an equilibrium real interest rate as the equilibrating force of saving and investment at full employment levels. Rather, it is based on the notion that modern capitalist economies face aggregate demand constraints, and that saving adjusts to investment through income growth and changes in capacity utilisation in the long run. Steindl’s treatment allows for potential growth to become endogenous to actual demand, and it seriously considers the role of institutions and power relationships for long-run growth. In illustrating Steindl’s contributions on this topic, the article presents an original model synthetizing the main points in particular concerning long run growth and stagnation.

 

JEL codes: B22, E11, E12, E65, O11

References

Backhouse R.E. and Boianovsky M. (2015), “Secular Stagnation: The History of a Macroeconomic Heresy, Version 1”, preliminary draft of a paper prepared for the Blanqui Lecture, Meetings of the European Society for the History of Economic Thought, Rome, 14 May. >

Baran P.A. and Sweezy P.M. (1966), Monopoly Capital, New York: Monthly Review Press.>

Bhaduri A. and Steindl J. (1985), “The Rise of Monetarism as a Social Doctrine”, in Arestis P. and Skouras T. (eds.), Post-Keynesian Economic Theory, Sussex: Wheatsheaf.>

Blanchard O., Dell’Ariccia G. and Mauro P. (2010), “Rethinking Macroeconomic Policy”, IMF Staff Position Note, n. SPN/10/03, Washington (DC): International Monetary Fund.>

Blanchard O., Furceri D. and Pescatori A. (2014), “A Prolonged Period of Low Real Interest Rates?”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Bleany M. (1976), Underconsumption Theories. History and Critical Analysis, New York: International Publishers.>

Blecker R.A. (2002), “Distribution, Demand and Growth in Neo-Kaleckian Macro-models”, in Setterfield M. (ed.), The Economics of Demand-Led Growth, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.>

Cowling K. (1982), Monopoly Capitalism, London: Macmillan.>

Crafts N. (2014), “Secular Stagnation, US Hypochondria, European Disease?”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Dallery T. and van Treeck T. (2011), “Conflicting Claims and Equilibrium Adjustment Processes in a Stock-flow Consistent Macro Model”, Review of Political Economy, vol. 23, pp. 189-211.>

Duménil G. and Lévy D. (1999), “Being Keynesian in the Short Term and Classical in the Long Term: The Traverse to Classical Long-term Equilibrium”, The Manchester School, vol. 67, pp. 684-716.>

Dutt A.K. (1990a), Growth, Distribution and Uneven Development, Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press.>

Dutt A.K. (1990b), “Growth, Distribution and Capital Ownership: Kalecki and Pasinetti Revisited”, in Dutta B., Gangopadhyay S., Mookherjee D. and Ray D. (eds.), Economic Theory and Policy. Essays in Honour of Dipak Banerjee, Bombay: Oxford University Press.>

Dutt A.K. (1995), “Internal Finance and Monopoly Power in Capitalist Economies: A Reformulation of Steindl’s Growth Model”, Metroeconomica, vol. 46, pp. 16-34.>

Dutt A.K. (2005), “Steindl’s Theory of Maturity and Stagnation and Its Relevance Today”, in Mott T. and Shapiro N. (eds.), Rethinking Capitalism. Essays on the Economics of Josef Steindl, London and New York: Routledge.>

Dutt A.K. (2010), “Equilibrium, Stability and Path Dependence in Post Keynesian Models of Economic Growth”, in Birolo A., Foley D., Kurz H.D. and Steedman I. (eds.), Production, Distribution and Trade: Alternative Perspectives, London: Routledge. >

Eggertsson G.B. and Mehrotra N.R. (2014a), “A Model of Secular Stagnation”, NBER Working paper, n. 20574, Cambridge (MA): National Bureau for Economic Research.>

Eggertsson G.B. and Mehrotra N.R. (2014b), “A Model of Secular Stagnation”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Flaschel P. and Skott P. (2006), “Steindlian Models of Growth and Stagnation”, Metroeconomica vol. 57, pp. 303-338.>

Foster J.B. (1987), “What is Stagnation?”, in Cherry R. (ed.), The Imperiled Economy, Book I, Macroeconomics from a Left Perspective, New York: URPE.>

Foster J.B. (2014), The Theory of Monopoly Capitalism: An Elaboration of Marxian Political Economy, New York: Monthly Review Press.>

Foster J.B. and McChesney R.W. (2012), The Endless Crisis: How Monopoly-Finance Capital Produces Stagnation and Upheaval from the USA to China, New York: Monthly Review Press.>

Franke R. (2015), “A Supplementary Note on Professor Hein’s (2013) Version of a Kaleckian Debt Accumulation”, Metroeconomica, early view, DOI: 10.1111/meca.12110. >

Glaeser E.L. (2014), “Secular Joblessness”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Gordon R. (2012), “Is US Economic Growth Over? Faltering Innovation Confronts the Six Headwinds”, NBER Working Paper, n. 18315, Cambridge (MA): National Bureau for Economic Research. >

Gordon R. (2014), “The Turtle’s Progress: Secular Stagnation Meets the Headwinds”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Guger A., Marterbauer M. and Walterskirchen E. (2006), “Growth Policy in the Spirit of Steindl and Kalecki”, Metroeconomica, vol. 57, pp. 428-442.>

Hansen A.H. (1934), “Capital Goods and the Restoration of Purchasing Power”, Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science, vol. 16 n. 1, pp. 11-19.>

Hansen A.H. (1939), “Economic Progress and Declining Population Growth”, American Economic Review, vol. 29 n. 1, pp. 1-15.>

Harcourt G.C. (1969), “Some Cambridge Controversies in the Theory of Capital”, Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 7, pp. 369-405. >

Harcourt G.C. (1972), Some Cambridge Controversies in the Theory of Capital, Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press. >

Harrod R.F. (1939), “An Essay in Dynamic Theory”, The Economic Journal, vol. 49, pp. 14-33.>

Hein E. (2006), “On the (In-)stability and the Endogeneity of the ‘Normal’ Rate of Capacity Utilisation in a Post-Keynesian/Kaleckian ‘Monetary’ Distribution and Growth Model”, Indian Development Review, vol. 4, pp. 129-150.>

Hein E. (2008), Money, Distribution Conflict and Capital Accumulation. Contributions to ‘Monetary Analysis’, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan>

Hein E. (2010), “Shareholder Value Orientation, Distribution and Growth – Short- and Medium-run Effects in a Kaleckian Model”, Metroeconomica, vol. 61, pp. 302-332.>

Hein E. (2011), “Redistribution, Global Imbalances and the Financial and Economic Crisis – The Case for a Keynesian New Deal”, International Journal of Labour Research, vol. 3 n. 1, pp. 51-73. >

Hein E. (2012a), The Macroeconomics of Finance-dominated Capitalism – And its Crisis, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.>

Hein E. (2012b), “‘Financialisation’, Distribution, Capital Accumulation and Productivity Growth in a Post-Kaleckian Model”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 34, pp. 475-496.>

Hein E. (2013), “On the Importance of the Retention Ratio in a Kaleckian Distribution and Growth Model with Debt Accumulation – A Comment on Sasaki and Fujita (2012)”, Metroeconomica, vol. 64 pp. 186-196.>

Hein E. (2014), Distribution and Growth after Keynes: A Post-Keynesian Guide, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.>

Hein E. (2016), “Secular Stagnation or Stagnation Policy? A Steindlian View”, European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies: Intervention, vol. 13, forthcoming.>

Hein E. and Dodig N. (2015), “Financialisation, Distribution, Growth and Crises – Long-run Tendencies”, in Hein E., Detzer D. and Dodig N. (eds), The Demise of Finance-dominated Capitalism: Explaining the Financial and Economic Crises, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.>

Hein E., Lavoie M. and van Treeck, T. (2011), “Some Instability Puzzles in Kaleckian Models of Growth and Distribution: A Critical Survey”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 35, pp. 587-612. >

Hein E., Lavoie M. and van Treeck T. (2012), “Harrodian Instability and the ‘Normal Rate’ of Capacity Utilisation in Kaleckian models of Distribution and Growth – A Survey”, Metroeconomica, vol. 63, pp. 139-169. >

Hein E. and Mundt M. (2012), “Financialisation and the Requirements and Potentials for Wage-led Recovery – A Review Focussing on the G20”, Conditions of Work and Employment Series, n. 37, Geneva: International Labour Organization.>

Hein E. and Truger A. (2011), “Finance-dominated Capitalism in Crisis – the Case for a Keynesian New Deal at the European and the Global Level”, in Arestis P. and Sawyer M. (eds.), New Economics as Mainstream Economics, International Papers in Political Economy, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. >

Hein E. and Truger A. (2012), “Finance-dominated Capitalism in Crisis – The Case for a Global Keynesian New Deal”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 35, pp. 183-210. >

Hein E. and van Treeck T. (2010), “‘Financialisation’ in Post-Keynesian Models of Distribution and Growth – A Systematic Review”, in Setterfield M. (ed.), Handbook of Alternative Theories of Economic Growth, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. >

Hicks J. (1932), The Theory of Wages, London: Macmillan. >

Hobson J.A. (1902), Imperialism: A Study, New York: James Pott & Company.>

Horn G., Joebges H. and Zwiener R. (2009), “From the Financial Crisis to the World Economic Crisis (II). Global imbalances: Cause of the Crisis and Solution Strategies for Germany”, IMK Policy Brief, Duesseldorf: Macroeconomic Policy Institute (IMK) at Hans-Boeckler Foundation. >

ILO (2012), Global Wage Report. Wages and Equitable Growth, Geneva: International Labour Organization. >

Kaldor N. (1957), “A Model of Economic Growth”, The Economic Journal, vol. 67, pp. 591-624; reprinted in Kaldor N. (1960), Collected Economic Essays, Volume 2, Essays on Economic Stability and Growth, London: Duckworth. >

Kaldor N. (1961), “Capital Accumulation and Economic Growth”, in Lutz F.A. and Hague D.C. (eds.), The Theory of Capital, London: Macmillan; reprinted in Kaldor N. (1978), Collected Economic Essays, Volume 5, Further Essays on Economic Theory, London: Duckworth. >

Kaldor N. (1966), Causes of the Slow Rate of Economic Growth in the United Kingdom, Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press; reprinted in Kaldor N. (1978), Collected Economic Essays, Volume 5, Further Essays on Economic Theory, London: Duckworth. >

Kalecki M. (1937), “The Principle of Increasing Risk”, Economica, vol. 4, pp. 440-447.>

Kalecki M. (1954), Theory of Economic Dynamics, London: George Allen and Unwin.>

Kalecki M. (1971), Selected Essays on the Dynamics of the Capitalist Economy, 1933-70, Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press.>

Keynes J.M. (1936), The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, in Keynes J.M. (1973), The Collected Writings of J.M. Keynes, vol. VII, London and Basingstoke: Macmillan.>

Keynes J.M. (1943), “The Long-term Problem of Full Employment”, in Keynes J.M. (1980), The Collected Writings of J.M. Keynes, vol. XXVII, London: Macmillan. >

King J.E. (1995), “Outside the Mainstream: Josef Steindl’s Economic Papers 1941-88”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 19, pp. 463-475.>

Koo R. (2013), “Balance Sheet Recession as the ‘Other Half’ of Macroeconomics”, European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies: Intervention, vol. 10, pp. 136-157.>

Koo R. (2014), “Balance Sheet Recession is the Reason for Secular Stagnation”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Krugman P. (2014), “Four Observations on Secular Stagnation”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Lavoie M. (1992), Foundations of Post Keynesian Economic Analysis, Aldershot, Brookfield: Edward Elgar. >

Lavoie M. (1995a), “The Kaleckian Model of Growth and Distribution and its Neo-Ricardian and Neo-Marxian Critiques”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 19, pp. 789-818.>

Lavoie M. (1995b), “Interest Rates in Post-Keynesian Models of Growth and Distribution”, Metroeconomica, vol. 46, pp. 146-177.>

Lavoie M. (1996), “Traverse, Hysteresis and Normal Rates of Capacity Utilization in Kaleckian Models of Growth and Distribution”, Review of Radical Political Economics, vol. 28 n. 4, pp. 113-147.>

Lavoie M. and Stockhammer E. (eds.) (2013a), Wage-led Growth: An Equitable Strategy for Economic Recovery, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. >

Lavoie M. and Stockhammer E. (2013b), “Wage-led Growth: Concept, Theories and Policies”, in Lavoie M. and Stockhammer E. (eds.), Wage-led Growth: An Equitable Strategy for Economic Recovery, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. >

Lazzarini A. (2011), Revisiting the Cambridge Capital Controversies: A Historical and Analytical Study, Pavia: Pavia University Press. >

Lee F.S. (1998), Post Keynesian Price Theory, Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press.>

Luxemburg R. (1913), Die Akkumulation des Kapitals. Ein Beitrag zur ökonomischen Erklärung des Imperialismus, Berlin: Vorwärts; English translation (1951), The Accumulation of Capital, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.>

Marx K. (1867), Das Kapital. Kritik der politischen Ökonomie, Erster Band: Der Produktionsprozeß des Kapitals, 4th edition 1890, edited by F. Engels; reprinted as Marx K. and Engels F. (1962), Werke, Volume 23, Berlin: Dietz Verlag; English translation (1967), Capital. A Critique of Political Economy, Volume 1: The Process of Capitalist Production, New York: International Publisher. >

Mazzucato M. (2013), The Entrepreneurial State: Debunking Public vs. Private Sector Myths, London: Anthem Press.>

Mazzucato M. and Penna C.C.R. (2015), “Beyond Market Failures: The Market Creating and Shaping Roles of State Investment Banks”, Levy Economics Institute Working Paper, n. 831, Annandale-on-Hudson (NY): Bard College. >

Meade J.E. (1975), “The Keynesian Revolution”, in Keynes M. (ed.), Essays on John Maynard Keynes, Cambridge (UK): Cambridge University Press.>

Mokyr J. (2014), “Secular Stagnation? Not in Our Life”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Mott T. and Shapiro N. (2005), (eds.), Rethinking Capitalist Development: Essays on the Economics of Josef Steindl, London and New York: Routledge.>

OECD (2015), Escaping from the Stagnation Trap: Policy Options for the Euro Area and Japan, Paris: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.>

Palley T.I. (2012), From Financial Crisis to Stagnation: The Destruction of Shared Prosperity and the Role of Economics, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. >

Palley T.I. (2013), Financialization: The Economics of Finance Capital Domination, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. >

Robinson J. (1962), Essays in the Theory of Economic Growth, London: Macmillan.>

Rowthorn R.E. (1981), “Demand, Real Wages and Economic Growth”, Thames Papers in Political Economy, Autumn, pp. 1-39. >

Sasaki H. and Fujita S. (2012), “The Importance of the Retention Ratio in a Kaleckian Model with Debt Accumulation”, Metroeconomica, vol. 63, pp. 417-428.>

Shaikh A. (2009), “Economic Policy in a Growth Context: a Classical Synthesis of Keynes and Harrod”, Metroeconomica, vol. 60, pp. 455–494.>

Shapiro N. (2012), “Josef Steindl: an Economist of His Times”, PSL Quarterly Review, vol. 65, pp. 167-187.>

Skott P. (2010), “Growth, Instability and Cycles: Harrodian and Kaleckian Models of Accumulation and Income Distribution”, in Setterfield M. (ed.), Handbook of Alternative Theories of Economic Growth, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.>

Skott P. (2012), “Theoretical and Empirical Shortcomings of the Kaleckian Investment Function”, Metroeconomica, vol. 63, pp. 109-138.>

Steedman I. (1977), Marx after Sraffa, London: NLB.>

Steindl J. (1952), Maturity and Stagnation in American Capitalism, Oxford: Blackwell; 2nd edition 1976, New York and London: Monthly Review Press.>

Steindl J. (1964), “On maturity in Capitalist Economies”, in VV.AA., Problems of Economic Dynamics and Planning: Essays in Honour of Michal Kalecki, Warsaw: PWN-Polish Scientific Publishers.>

Steindl J. (1976), “Introduction”, in (id.), Maturity and Stagnation in American Capitalism, 2nd edition, New York and London: Monthly Review Press.>

Steindl J. (1979), “Stagnation Theory and Stagnation Policy”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 3, pp. 1-14; reprinted in Steindl J. (1990), Economic Papers, 1941-88, Basingstoke: Macmillan.>

Steindl J. (1981a), “Some Comments on the Three Versions of Kalecki’s Theory of the Trade Cycle”, in Los J. (ed.), Studies in Economic Theory and Practice. Essays in Honour of Edward Lipinski, Amsterdam: North-Holland; reprinted in Steindl J. (1990), Economic Papers, 1941-88, Basingstoke: Macmillan.>

Steindl J. (1981b), “Ideas and Concepts of Long Run Growth”, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, vol. 34 n. 136, pp. 35-48; reprinted in Steindl J. (1990), Economic Papers, 1941-88, Basingstoke: Macmillan.>

Steindl J. (1985), “Distribution and Growth”, Political Economy. Studies in the Surplus Approach vol. 1, pp. 53-68; reprinted in Steindl J. (1990), Economic Papers, 1941-88, Basingstoke: Macmillan. >

Steindl J. (1989), “From Stagnation in the 30s to Slow Growth in the 70s”, in Berg M. (ed.), Political Economy in the Twentieth Century, Oxford: Philip Allan; reprinted in Steindl J. (1990), Economic Papers, 1941-88, Basingstoke: Macmillan.>

Stockhammer E. (2010), “Income Distribution, the Finance-dominated Accumulation Regime, and the Present Crisis”, in Dullien S., Hein E., Truger A. and van Treeck T. (eds), The World Economy in Crisis – the Return of Keynesianism?, Marburg: Metropolis.>

Stockhammer E. (2012), “Financialization, Income Distribution and the Crisis”, Investigación Económica, vol. 71 n. 279, pp. 39-70.>

Stockhammer E. (2015), “Rising Inequality as a Cause of the Present Crisis”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 39, pp. 935-958. >

Stockhammer E. and Onaran Ö. (2012), “Rethinking Wage Policy in the Face of the Euro Crisis: Implications of the Wage-led Demand Regime”, International Review of Applied Economics, vol. 26, pp. 191-203.>

Stockhammer E. and Onaran Ö. (2013), “Wage-led Growth: Theory, Evidence, Policy”, Review of Keynesian Economics, vol. 1, pp. 61-78.>

Summers L.A. (2013), “Remarks at the IMF Economic Forum”, presented at the 14th Jacques Polak Annual Research Conference – Crises: Yesterday and Today, Washington (DC), 8 November, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KYpVzBbQIX0.>

Summers L.A. (2014a), “U.S. Economic Prospects: Secular Stagnation, Hysteresis, and the Zero Lower Bound”, Business Economics, vol. 49 n. 2, pp. 65-73.>

Summers L.A. (2014b), “Reflections on the ‘New Secular Stagnation Hypothesis’”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR). >

Summers L.A. (2015), “Demand Side Secular Stagnation”, American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings, vol. 105 n. 5, pp. 60-65.>

Sweezy P.M. (1942), Theory of Capitalist Development, New York: Oxford University Press.>

Taylor L. (1991), Income Distribution, Inflation, and Growth. Lectures on Structuralist Macroeconomic Theory, Cambridge (MA), and London: MIT Press. >

Taylor L. (2008), Reconstructing Macroeconomics. Structuralist Proposals and Critiques of the Mainstream, New Delhi: Viva Books. >

Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (eds.), (2014a), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

Teulings C. and Baldwin R. (2014b), “Introduction”, in Teulings C. and Baldwin, R. (eds.), Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures. A VoxEU.org eBook, London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR).>

UNCTAD (2009), The Global Economic Crisis. Systemic Failures and Multilateral Remedies, New York and Geneva: United Nations Commission on Trade And Development.>

Van Treeck T. and Sturn S. (2012), “Income Inequality as a Cause of the Great Recession? A Survey of Current Debates”, Conditions of Work and Employment Series, n. 39, Geneva: International Labour Organization.

Downloads

Published

2016-04-07

How to Cite

Hein, E. (2016). Secular stagnation or stagnation policy? Steindl after Summers. PSL Quarterly Review, 69(276), 3–47. https://doi.org/10.13133/2037-3643_69.276_1

Issue

Section

Articles