Forever young? Marx’s Critique of political economy after 200 years


  • Riccardo Bellofiore University of Bergamo



Marx, value, money, crisis, macro-monetary theory of capitalist production


This article suggests a reconstruction of Marx’s Critique of political economy as a macro-monetary theory of capitalist production. The first part of what follows will provide a sort of methodological introduction to Das Kapital. I am questioning the meaning of critique versus criticism, the distinction between fetish-character and fetishism, the role of dialectics, and the difference between reading, interpreting and reconstructing. I will focus especially on volume I. At the centre of the discussion are: the multiple meanings of abstract labour and socialization, the role of money as a commodity for the labour theory of value, the ‘method of comparison’ in grounding valorisation (the emergence of gross profits) as the constitution of capital from class struggle in production, the unity of absolute and relative surplus value extraction, the key notion of Technologie in the real subsumption of labour to capital, the law of the tendential fall in relative wage, Marx’s two notions of competition, and the macro-monetary class perspective in capitalist reproduction crucial to Capital, volume I. Some considerations are devoted to the transformation problem, the so-called “New Interpretation”, and crisis theory.

JEL codes: B14, B24, B51

KeywordsMarx, value, money, crisis, macro-monetary theory of capitalist production


Adorno T.W. ([1966] 1990), Negative Dialectics, London: Routledge.

Adorno T.W. ([1968] 2002), Introduction to Sociology, Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Aglietta M. (1976), A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US Experience, London: New Left Books.

Aglietta M. and Orléan A. (1982), La Violence de la monnaie, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.

Althusser L., Balibar É., Establet R., Macherey P. and Rancière J. (2016), Reading Capital: The Complete Edition. London: Verso.

Arthur C.J. (2002), The New Dialectic and Marx’s ‘Capital’, Leiden and Boston: Brill.

Backhaus H.-G. (1997), Dialektik der Wertform. Untersuchungen zur Marxschen Ökonomiekritik, Freiburg: ça ira.

Balibar É. ([1993] 1995), The Philosophy of Marx. London: Verso.

Bellofiore R. (2004), “Marx and the macro-economic foundation of microeconomics”, in Bellofiore R. and Taylor N. (eds.), The Constitution of Capital: Essays on Volume One of Marx’s Capital (pp. 170-210), Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bellofiore R. (2008), “A Ghost Turning into a Vampire: The Concept of Capital and Living Labour”, in Bellofiore R. and Fineschi R. (eds.), Re-reading Marx. New Perspectives after the Critical Edition (pp. 178-194), Houndsmill, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bellofiore R. (2011), “Crisis Theory and the Great Recession: A Personal Journey, from Marx to Minsky”, Research in Political Economy, 27, pp. 81-120.

Bellofiore R. (2014a), “Lost in Translation: Once Again on the Marx–Hegel Connection”, in Moseley F. and Smith T. (eds.), Marx’s Capital and Hegel’s Logic. A Reexamination (pp. 164-188), Leiden: Brill.

Bellofiore R. (2014b), “The Loneliness of the Long Distance Thinker: Sraffa, Marx, and the Critique of Economic Theory”, in Bellofiore R. and Carter S. (eds.), Towards a New Understanding of Sraffa. Insights from Archival Research (pp. 198-240), Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bellofiore R. (2014c), “The Great Recession and the Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism”, in Bellofiore R. and Vertova G. (eds.), The Great Recession and the Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism (pp. 7-25), Cheltenham (UK) and Northampton (MA, USA): Edward Elgar.

Bellofiore R. (2018a), “The Adventures of Vergesellschaftung”, Consecutio Rerum, 2 (5), available at:

Bellofiore R. (2018b), Le avventure della socializzazione. Dalla teoria monetaria del valore alla teoria macro-monetaria della produzione capitalistica, Milano: Mimesis.

Benetti C. and Cartelier J. (1980), Marchands, salariat et capitalistes, Paris: La Découverte.

Colletti L. ([1969a] 1972), From Rousseau to Lenin, London: NLB.

Colletti L. ([1969b] 1973), Marxism and Hegel, London: NLB.

Coriat B. (1979), L’atelier et le chronomètre : Essai sur le taylorisme, le fordisme et la production de masse, Paris: Christian Bourgois.

Croce B. ([1900] 1914), Historical Materialism and the Economics of Karl Marx, New York: Macmillan.

Crotty J. (2000), “Slow Growth, Destructive Competition, and Low Road Labor Relations: A Keynes-Marx-Schumpeter Analysis of Neoliberal Globalization”, PERI Working Paper Series, no. 6, November, Amherst (MA): Political Economy Research Institute, University of Massachusetts Amherst.

De Brunhoff S. ([1967] 2016), Marx on Money, London: Verso.

De Brunhoff S. ([1976] 1978), The State, Capital and Economic Policy, London: Pluto Press.

De Vroey M. (1979), “Travail abstrait, valeur et marchandise. Une réinterprétation de la théorie de la valeur de Marx”, Cahier de Recherche, no. 7912 (1st part) and no. 8016 (2nd part), Montreal: Départment de Sciences Economiques, Université de Montréal.

Desai M. (1998a), “Profitability, Prices and Values”, in Bellofiore R. (ed.), Marxian Economics: A Reappraisal, Volume 2, Essays on Volume III of Capital Profit, Prices and Dynamics (pp. 3-13), Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Desai M. (1998b), “Profitability and the Persistence of Capitalism”, in Bellofiore R. (ed.), Marxian Economics: A Reappraisal, Volume 2, Essays on Volume III of Capital Profit, Prices and Dynamics (pp. 291-303), Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Dobb M. (1937), Political Economy and Capitalism: Some Essays in Economic Tradition, London: Routledge.

Dobb M. (1967), “Marx’s Capital and Its Place in Economic Thought”, Science and Society, 31 (2), pp. 527-540 (originally published in Italian in 1964).

Dobb M. (1973), Theories of Value and Distribution since Adam Smith: Ideology and Economic Theory, London: Cambridge University Press.

Duménil G. (1980), De la valeur aux prix de production: une réinterprétation de la transformation, Paris: Economica.

Elson D. ([1979] 2016), Value: The Representation of Labour in Capitalism, London: Verso.

Finelli R. (1987), Astrazione e dialettica dal Romanticismo al capitalismo (saggio su Marx), Roma: Bulzoni.

Finelli R. (2014), Un parricidio compiuto. Il confronto finale di Marx con Hegel, Milano: Jaca Book.

Foley D. (1986), Understanding Capital. Marx’s Economic Theory, Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.

Foley D. (2000), “Recent Developments in the Labor Theory of Value”, Review of Radical Political Economics, 32 (1), pp. 1-39.

Frison G. (1993), “Linnaeus, Beckmann, Marx and the Foundation of Technology. Between Natural and Social Sciences: a Hypothesis of an Ideal Type. Second and Third Part: Beckmann, Marx, Technology and Classical Economics”, History and Technology, 10 (2-3), pp. 161-173.

Garegnani P. (1984), “Value and Distribution in the Classical Economists and Marx”, Oxford Economic Papers, 36 (2), pp. 291-325.

Glyn A. (2006), Capitalism Unleashed: Finance, Globalisation and Welfare, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Graziani A. ([1983] 1997a), “Let’s Rehabilitate the Theory of Value”, International Journal of Political Economy, 27 (2), pp. 21-25.

Graziani A. ([1986] 1997b), “The Marxist Theory of Money”, International Journal of Political Economy, 27 (2), pp. 26-50.

Grossmann H. ([1941] 1977), “Marx, Classical Political Economy and the Problem of Dynamics”, Capital and Class, 1 (2), pp. 32-55 (Part I); 1 (3), pp. 67-99 (Part II).

Hai-Hac T. (2003), Relire "Le Capital". Marx, critique de l’économie politique et objet de la critique de l’économie politique, 2 volumes, Lausanne: Ed. Page Deux.

Hegel G.W.F. ([1830] 1991), The Encyclopaedia Logic: Part I of the Encyclopaedia of Philosophical Sciences with the “Zusätze”, translated from the 3rd edition by T.F. Geraets, W.A. Suchting and H.S. Harris, Indianapolis: Hackett.

Heinrich M. (1999), Die Wissenschaft vom Wert. Die Marxsche Kritik der politischen Ökonomie zwischen wissenschaftlicher Revolution und klassischer Tradition, Münster: Westfälisches Dampfboot.

Heinrich M. (2013), “Crisis Theory, the Law of the Tendency of the Profit Rate to Fall, and Marx’s Studies in the 1870s”, Monthly Review, 64 (11), pp. 15-31; available at:

Kalecki M. ([1967] 1991), “The Problem of Effective Demand with Tugan-Baranovsky and Rosa Luxemburg”, reprinted in Osiatynski J. (ed.), Collected Works of Michał Kalecki, Volume I: Economic Dynamics (pp. 451–58), Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Korsch K. (1938), Karl Marx, London: Chapman & Hall.

Luporini C. (1974), Dialettica e materialismo, Roma: Editori Riuniti.

Luxemburg R. ([1925] 2013), Introduction to Political Economy, in The Complete Works of Rosa Luxemburg, Volume I: Economic Writings 1 (pp. 89-300), London: Verso.

Mattick P. (1969), Marx and Keynes. The Limits of the Mixed Economy, Boston: Extending Horizons Books/Porter Sargent Publisher.

Messori M. (1978), Sraffa e la critica dell’economia dopo Marx, Milano: Angeli.

Messori M. (1985), “Innovation et profit chez Marx, Schumpeter et Keynes”, Cahiers d’économie politique, 10-11, pp. 229-256.

Mohun S. (1994), “A Re(in)statement of the Labour Theory of Value”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 18 (4), pp. 391-412.

Moretti F. (1983), Signs Taken for Wonders: On the Sociology of Literary Forms, London: New Left Books.

Moseley F. (2015), Money and Totality. A Macro-Monetary Interpretation of Marx’s Logic in Capital and the End of the “Transformation Problem”, Leiden: Brill

Napoleoni C. (1973a), Intervento, Fondazione Agnelli, mimeo.

Napoleoni C. (1974), “Lotta politica e ‘leggi’ economiche”, il manifesto, 5 May, pp. 1-2.

Napoleoni C. ([1973b] 1975), Smith, Ricardo, Marx, Oxford: Blackwell.

Negri A. ([1979] 1984), Marx beyond Marx : Lessons on the ‘Grundrisse’, South Hadley (MA): Bergin & Garvey.

Pasinetti L.L. (1977), Lectures on the Theory of Production, New York: Columbia University Press.

Postone M. (1993), Time, Labor and Social Domination. A Reinterpretation of Marx’s Critical Theory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Rancière J. (2016), “The Concept of Critique and the Critique of Political Economy: From the 1844 Manuscripts to Capital”, in Althusser L., Balibar É., Establet R., Macherey P. and Rancière J., Reading Capital: The Complete Edition (pp. 62-134), London: Verso.

Reichelt H. ([1970] 2001), Zur logischen Struktur des Kapitalbegriffs bei Karl Marx, Freiburg: ça ira.

Reuten G. (2004), “‘Zirkel vicieux’ or Trend Fall? The Course of the Profit Rate in Marx’s Capital III”, History of Political Economy, 36 (1), pp. 163-186.

Rowthorn B. (1974), “Neo-Classicism, Neo-Ricardianism and Marxism”, New Left Review, 86, pp. 63-87.

Rubel M. ([1974] 2000), Marx critique du marxisme, Paris: Payot.

Rubin I.I. ([1928] 1973), Essay on Marx’s Theory of Value, 3rd edition, Montreal: Black Rose.

Rubin I.I. ([1926-1928] 2018), “Essay on Marx’s Theory of Money”, in Day R.B. and Gaido D. (eds.), Responses to Marx’s Capital: From Rudolf Hilferding to Isaak Illich Rubin (pp. 619-727), Leiden: Brill.

Schmidt A. ([1962] 1971), The Concept of Nature in Marx, London: New Left Books.

Schmidt A. ([1971] 1981), History and Structure. An Essay on Hegelian-Marxist and Structuralist Theories of History. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press.

Shaikh A. (1977), “Marx’s Theory of Value and the Transformation Problem”, in Schwartz J. (ed.), The Subtle Anatomy of Capitalism (pp. 106-139), Calver City (CA):Goodyear Publishing Co.

Shaikh A. (2016), Capitalism: Competition, Conflict, Crises. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sraffa P. (1960), Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Steedman I. (1977), Marx after Sraffa, London: NLR books.

Suchting W. (1995), ‘Critique’, ‘Ideology’, and ‘Science’ in Marx, mimeo.

Sweezy P.M. ([1942] 1970), The Theory of Capitalist Development. Principles of Marxian Political Economy, New York: Monthly Review Press.

Thomas P.D. and Reuten G. (2013), “Crisis and the Rate of Profit in Marx’s Laboratory”, in Bellofiore R., Starosta G. and Thomas P.D., Marx's Laboratory. Critical Interpretations of the ‘Grundrisse’ (pp. 311-328), Leiden: Brill.

Thompson E.P. ([1963] 1991), The Making of the English Working Class, London: Penguin Books.

Tomba M. (2011), Marx’s Temporalities, Leiden: Brill.

Toporowski J. (2010), “The Wisdom of Property and the Politics of the Middle Classes”, Monthly Review, 61, (4), pp. 10-15.

Turchetto M. (1981), “L’organizzazione del lavoro nella dinamica attuale del modo di produzione capitalistico”, in Turchetto M., Ciabatti G., Illuminati A., La Grassa G., Consiglio F., Fiorani E. and Geymonat L., Lavoro, scienza, potere (pp. 7-58), Milano: Feltrinelli.

Turchetto M. (1991), “The Divided Machine: Capitalist Crisis and the Organization of Labor”, Marxism and Contemporary Philosophy, 14 (1), pp. 209-240.

Varoufakis Y., Halevi J. and Theocarakis N. (2011), Modern Political Economics. Making Sense of the Post-2008 world. London: Routledge.

Vertova G. (2016), “Crisis, Policy Responses and Gender: The Italian Experience”, in Bargawi H., Cozzi G. and Himmelweit S. (eds.), Economics and Austerity in Europe: Gendered Impacts and Sustainable Alternatives (pp. 59-75), London: Routledge.

Wray R.L. (1998), “Preliminaries to a Monetary Theory of Production: The Labour Theory of Value, Liquidity Preference and the Two Price Systems”, in Bellofiore R. (ed.), Marxian Economics: A Reappraisal. Volume I: Essays on Volume III of Capital (pp. 286-300), Basingstoke: Macmillan.




How to Cite

Bellofiore, R. (2019). Forever young? Marx’s Critique of political economy after 200 years. PSL Quarterly Review, 71(287), 353–388.