Competitive vs cumulative approach in teaching macroeconomics: Some thoughts on recent popular textbooks


  • Emilio Carnevali



Teaching of economics, monetary policy, IS-LM model


This paper critically evaluates two different approaches to teaching macroeconomics at the undergraduate level through the comparison of two popular, recent handbooks: Olivier Blanchard’s Macroeconomics (2021) and William Mitchell, Randall Wray and Martin Watts’s Macroeconomics (2019). These textbooks are taken as benchmarks of two opposite views of the discipline: the cumulative – that is, followed by Blanchard and most “mainstream” textbooks – as opposed to the competitive view.



JEL codes: A2, A22, E5, E12


Bellofiore R. (2018), “Eleven theses on political economy and ‘rethinking economics’: the role of the history of economic thought in the ‘Italian tradition’”, in Tavasci D. and Ventimiglia L. (eds.), Teaching the History of Economic Thought (pp. 65-74), Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Blanchard O. (2018), “On the future of macroeconomic models”, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 34 (1-2), pp. 43-54.

Blanchard O. (2021), Macroeconomics, 8th ed., Harlow, UK: Pearson.

Blanchard O. and Summers L.H. (2019), “Ripensare le politiche macroeconomiche: evoluzione o rivoluzione?”, Moneta e Credito, 72 (287), pp. 171-195.

Brancaccio E. (2021), Anti-Blanchard: un approccio comparato allo studio della macroeconomia, 5th ed., Milan: FrancoAngeli.

Brancaccio E. and Bibi S. (2021), Anti-Blanchard, Lima: Universidad Peruana de Ciencias Aplicadas (UPC).

Brancaccio E. and Califano A. (2019), Anti-Blanchard Macroeconomics: A Comparative Approach, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Brancaccio E. and Califano A. (2022), Anti-Blanchard Macroeconomics: A Comparative Approach, 2nd ed., Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Carlin W.J. and Soskice D.W. (1990), Macroeconomics and the Wage Bargain: A Modern Approach to Employment, Inflation, and the Exchange Rate, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2017), “The role of banks, non-banks and the central bank in the money creation process”, Monthly Report, 69 (4), pp. 13-33.

D’Ippoliti C. (2020), Democratizing the Economics Debate: Pluralism and Research Evaluation, London: Routledge.

D’Ippoliti C. and Roncaglia A. (2016), “Heterodox economics and the history of economic thought”, in Jo T.-H. and Todorova Z. (eds.), Advancing the Frontiers of Heterodox Economics: Essays in Honor of Frederic S. Lee (pp. 21-38), London: Routledge.

Fike R. and Gwartney J. (2015), “Public Choice, Market Failure, and Government Failure in Principles Textbooks”, The Journal of Economic Education, 46 (2), pp. 207-218.

FOMC (2019), Statement Regarding Monetary Policy Implementation and Balance Sheet Normalization, press release, available at:

Hicks J.R. (1937), “Mr Keynes and the ‘Classics’: A Suggested Interpretation”, Econometrica, 5 (2), pp. 147-159.

Holmgren M. (2017), “From continuous to discrete: An alternative approach to teaching consumer choice”, Journal of Economics Teaching, 2 (1), pp. 1-13.

Ihrig J.E., Weinbach G.C. and Wolla S.A. (2021), “Teaching the Linkage between Banks and the Fed: RIP Money Multiplier”, Page One Economics Newsletter, 17 September, available at:

Ihrig J.E. and Wolla S. (2020), “Let’s close the gap: Revising teaching materials to teach how the Federal Reserve implements monetary policy”, Finance and Economics Discussion Series, n. 2020-092, Washington (DC): Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (US).

Keynes J.M. (1936), The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, 2017 ed., Ware, UK: Wordsworth Editions.

Kuhn T. (1970), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd ed., Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Lakatos I. (1970), “Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes”, in Lakatos I. and Musgrave A. (eds.), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge (pp. 91-196), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lavoie M. (2013), “The monetary and fiscal nexus of neo-chartalism: a friendly critique, Journal of Economic Issues, 47 (1), pp. 1-32.

Lavoie M. (2015), Post-Keynesian economics: New foundations, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Lipsey R.G. (1960), “The Relation between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wage Rates in the United Kingdom, 1862-1957: A Further Analysis”, Economica, 27 (105), pp. 1-31.

Madsen P.T. (2013), “The Financial Crisis and Principles of Economics Textbooks”, The Journal of Economic Education, 44 (3), pp. 197-216.

Mankiw N. Gregory (2016), “Response: The Tradeoff between Nuance and Clarity”, Eastern Economic Journal, 42 (2), pp. 169-70.

McLeay M., Radia A. and Thomas R. (2014), “Money creation in the modern economy”, Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, 2014 (Q1), pp. 14-27.

Mearman A., Guizzo D. and Berger S. (2018), “Is UK economics teaching changing? Evaluating the new subject benchmark statement”, Review of Social Economy, 76 (3), pp. 377-396.

Mitchell W., Wray R. and Watts M. (2019), Macroeconomics, London: Red Globe Press.

Phillips A.W. (1958), “The Relation between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wage Rates in the United Kingdom, 1861-1957”, Economica, 25 (100), pp. 283-299.

Roncaglia A. (1996), “Why should economists study the history of economic thought?”, European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 3 (2), pp. 296-309.

Roncaglia A. (2006), The Wealth of Ideas: A History of Economic Thought, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Samuelson P. (1990), “Foreword”, in Saunders P. and Walstad W.B. (eds.), The Principles of Economics Course: A Handbook for Instructors (pp. ix-x), New York: McGraw-Hill.

Samuelson P.A. and Solow R. (1960), “Analytical Aspects of Anti-Inflation Policy”, American Economic Review, 50 (2), pp. 177-194.

Siegfried J.J. (2000), “How Many College Students Are Exposed to Economics”, Journal of Economic Education, Spring, 31 (2), pp. 202-204.

Siegfried J.J. and Walstad W.B. (2014), “Undergraduate coursework in economics: A survey perspective”, The Journal of Economic Education, 45 (2), pp. 147-158.

Sylos Labini P. (1949), “The Keynesians (A letter from America to a friend)”, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, 2 (11), pp. 238-242.

Wolla S. (2018), “The Textbook Treatment of Net Exports: Will the Uninformed Reader Understand?”, Journal of Economics Teaching, 3 (2), pp. 233-253.




How to Cite

Carnevali, E. (2022). Competitive vs cumulative approach in teaching macroeconomics: Some thoughts on recent popular textbooks. PSL Quarterly Review, 75(301).



Book review article