Southern Europe and the Frugal Four: Pathological external indebtedness?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.13133/2037-3643/18610Keywords:
external debt, current account, growth models, comparative political economy, Southern Europe, Frugal FourAbstract
This research uses linear correlation and time-series analysis to examine the evolution of the external debt accumulated in periods of current account deficits and reserve purchases. Statistical data of GIPS countries (Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain), Ireland, and the United States show that a significant portion of the external debt cannot be explained by balance-of-payment (BoP) analysis. Similarly, the study finds that the external debt of the “Frugal Four” countries (Austria, Denmark, The Netherlands and Sweden) is also higher than explainable through BoP data. The research suggests that, due to the very structure of the international payment system, a country’s over-indebtedness is chronic in nature rather than due to behavioural or cultural factors. To tackle the issue, the development of international central banking is thus suggested.
References
Amable B. (2016), “Institutional complementarities in the dynamic comparative analysis of capitalism”, Journal of Institutional Economics, 12 (01), pp. 79-103.
Aspide A., Brown J.J., Di Giuseppe M. and Slaski A. (2022), “Culture & European Attitudes on Public Debt”, New Political Economy, 28(4), pp. 509-525. Available online.
Baccaro L. and Howell C. (2018), Trajectories of Neoliberal Transformation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Baccaro L. and Pontusson J. (2016), “Rethinking Comparative Political Economy”, Politics & Society, 44(2), pp. 175-207.
Barredo J. (2019), “The nature of capitalist money and the financial links between debt-led and export-led growth regimes”, New political economy, 24(4), pp. 565-586.
Behringer J. and Van Treeck T. (2018), “Income distribution and the current account”, Journal of International Economics, 114 (2018), pp. 238-254.
Behringer J. and van Treeck T. (2019), “Income distribution and growth models: a sectoral balances approach”, Politics & Society, 47(3), pp. 303-332.
Blyth M. and Matthijs M. (2017), “Black Swans, Lame Ducks, and the mystery of IPE's missing macroeconomics”, Review of International Political Economy, 24(2), pp. 203-231.
Blyth M., Pontusson J. and Baccaro L. (Eds.) (2022), Diminishing Returns: The New Politics of Growth and Stagnation, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Boyer R. (2000), “Is a finance-led growth regime a viable alternative to Fordism: A preliminary analysis”, Economy and society, 29(1), pp. 111-145.
Boyer R. (2018), “Comparative Political Economy”, in Cardinale I. and Scazzieri R. (eds.), The Palgrave handbook of political economy (pp. 543-603), London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Buendía L., Barredo J. and Balay J. (2022), “Foreign sector and welfare state in Sweden from complementarity to tensions”, Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 63, pp. 310-319.
Burroni L., Pavolini E. and Regini M. (eds.) (2022), Mediterranean Capitalism Revisited: One Model, Different Trajectories, Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press.
Cardenas L. and Arribas J. (eds.) (2021), Institutional Change after the Great Recession: European Growth Models at the Crossroads, London and New York: Routledge.
Carrera A. (2024), “Ideas y hechos del orden monetario internacional: sobre un Área Monetaria Integrada de Compensación en Argentina y Brasil”, Iberian Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 11(2), pp. 77-90.
Carrera A. and Cencini A. (2024), National and International Monetary Payments, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Carrera A., Cárdenas L. and Mazoni A. (2023), “An empirical comparison of external indebtedness in East Asia and Southern Europe: reasons for Clearing Integrated Monetary Areas”, Seoul Journal of Economics, 36(4), pp. 425-458.
Cencini A. and Schmitt B. (1991), External Debt Servicing. A vicious Circle, London: Pinters Publishers.
Crouch C. (2012), “Employment, consumption, debt, and European industrial relations systems”, Industrial Relations, 51(S1), pp. 389-412.
Dellepiane-Avellaneda S., Hardiman N. and Heras J.L. (2022), “Financial resource curse in the Eurozone periphery”, Review of International Political Economy, 29(4), pp. 1287-1313.
Dore R. (2008), “Financialization of the global economy”, Industrial and Corporate Change, 17(6), pp. 1097-1112.
Esping-Andersen G. (1990), The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Princeton (NJ): Princeton University Press.
Frieden J.A. and Walter S. (2017), “Understanding the political economy of the Eurozone crisis”, Annual Review of Political Science, 20(1), pp. 371-390.
Fuller G.W. (2017), “Exporting EMU Assets and the Financial Drivers of European Macroeconomic Imbalances”, New Political Economy, 23(2), pp. 174-191.
Gambarotto F. and Solari S. (2015), “The peripheralization of Southern European capitalism within the EMU”, Review of International Political Economy, 22(4), pp. 788-812.
Gräbner C., Heimberger P., Kapeller J. and Schütz B. (2020), “Is the Eurozone disintegrating? Macroeconomic divergence, structural polarisation, trade and fragility”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 44(3), pp. 647-669.
Guschanski A. and Stockhammer E. (2020), “Are current accounts driven by cost competitiveness or asset prices? A synthetic model and an empirical test”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 44(6), pp. 1301-1327.
Hancké B. (2013), Unions, central banks, and EMU labour market institutions and monetary integration in Europe, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hassel A. and Palier B. (Eds.) (2021), Growth and Welfare in Advanced Capitalist Economies: How Have Growth Regimes Evolved?, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hein E. (2013), “The crisis of finance-dominated capitalism in the euro area, deficiencies in the economic policy architecture, and deflationary stagnation policies”, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 36(2), pp. 325-354.
Hein E. and Martschin J. (2021), “Demand and growth regimes in finance-dominated capitalism and the role of the macroeconomic policy regime: a post-Keynesian comparative study on France, Germany, Italy and Spain before and after the Great Financial Crisis and the Great Recession”, Review of Evolutionary Political Economy, 2(3), pp. 493-527.
Hein E., Paternesi Meloni W. and Tridico P. (2020), “Welfare models and demand-led growth regimes before and after the financial and economic crisis”, Review of International Political Economy, 28(5), 2021, pp. 1196-1223
Höpner M. and Spielau A. (2018), “Better Than the Euro? The European Monetary System (1979-1998)”, New Political Economy, 23 (2), pp. 160-173.
IMF – International Monetary Fund (2022), “Total Reserves. International Financial Statistics and data files”, retrieved on September 20. Available online.
Klein M.C. and Pettis M. (2020), Trade wars are class wars. How rising inequality distorts the global economy and threatens international peace, Yale: Yale University Press.
Kohler K. and Stockhammer E. (2022), “Growing differently? Financial cycles, austerity, and competitiveness in growth models since the Global Financial Crisis”, Review of International Political Economy, 29(4), pp. 1314-1341.
Krippner G.R. (2005), “The financialization of the American economy”, Socio-economic review, 3 (2), pp. 173-208.
Krugman P., Obstfeld M. and Melitz M. (2017), International Economics, 10th edition, London: Pearson.
Lane P. and Milesi-Ferretti G.M. (2022), “The External Wealth of Nations Database. Brookings Institution”, retrieved on September 20. Available online.
Lavoie M. and Stockhammer E. (eds.) (2013), Wage-led Growth: An equitable strategy for economic recovery, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Nölke A. (2016), “Economic causes of the Eurozone crisis the analytical contribution of Comparative Capitalism”, Socio-Economic Review, 14 (1), pp. 141-161.
Pariboni R., Paternesi Meloni W. and Tridico P. (2020), “When melius abundare is no longer true: Excessive financialization and inequality as drivers of stagnation”, Review of Political Economy, 32 (2), pp. 216-242.
Pérez S.A. (2019), “A Europe of creditor and debtor states: explaining the north/south divide in the Eurozone”, West European Politics, 42 (5), pp. 989-1014.
Pérez S.A. and Matsaganis M. (2018), “The political economy of austerity in Southern Europe”, New Political Economy, 23 (2), pp. 192-207.
Pérez S.A. and Rhodes M. (2015), “The evolution and crises of the social models in Italy and Spain”, in Dølvik J.E. and Martin A. (eds), European Social Models, Inequality and Employment in the Era of Monetary Integration: From Crisis to Crisis (pp. 177-213), Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Picot G. (2021), “Cross-National Variation in Growth”, in Hassel A. and Palier B. (eds.), Growth and Welfare in Advanced Capitalist Economies: How Have Growth Regimes Evolved?, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pontusson J. and Weisstanner D. (2018), “Macroeconomic conditions, inequality shocks and the politics of redistribution, 1990–2013”, Journal of European Public Policy, 25(1), pp. 31-58.
Reale F. (2019), “Comparative institutional advantage: an obituary”, Journal of Institutional Economics, 15(4), pp. 569-578.
Regan A. (2017), “The imbalance of capitalisms in the Eurozone: Can the north and south of Europe converge?”, Comparative European Politics, 15(6), pp. 969-990.
Rossi S. (2017), “A structural-reform proposal for a two-speed European monetary union”, in da Costa Cabral N., Gonçalves J.R. and Cunha Rodrigues N. (eds.), The Euro and the Crisis: Perspectives for the Eurozone as a Monetary and Budgetary Union (pp. 33-46), Berlin: Springer.
Rossi S. (2019), “Rethinking the euro as a common currency for Europe: Keynes’s Plan revisited”, Revista de Economía Crítica, 27, pp. 86-99.
Schmitt B. (1973), New proposals for world monetary reform, Albeuve, Suiza: Castella.
Schmitt B. (1977), L’or, le dollar et la monnaie supranationale, Paris: Calman-Lévy.
Schmitt B. (2014), “The formation of sovereign debt: diagnosis and remedy”, Social Science Research Network, Available online.
Scholz-Alvarado C. (2021), “The Politics of Labour that Underlies European Monetary Integration”, Journal of Common Market Studies (JCMS), 60(5), pp. 1374-1390.
Simonazzi A., Ginzburg A. and Nocella G. (2013), “Economic relations between Germany and southern Europe”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 37(3), pp. 653-675.
Spielberger L. and Voss D. (2022), “Financial adjustment as a driver of growth model change: a balance-sheet approach to comparative political economy”, Comparative European Politics, Available online.
Stockhammer E. (2016), “Neoliberal growth models, monetary union and the Euro crisis. A post-Keynesian perspective”, New Political Economy, 21 (4), pp. 365-379.
Stockhammer E. and Otero A.N. (2022), “A tale of housing cycles and fiscal policy, not competitiveness. Growth drivers in southern Europe”, New Political Economy, 28(3), 2023, pp. 483-505. Available online.
Stockhammer E. and Wildauer R. (2016), “Debt-driven growth? Wealth, distribution and demand in OECD countries”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 40 (6), pp. 1609-1634.
Stockhammer E., Durand C. and List L. (2016), “European growth models and working class restructuring: an international post-Keynesian political economy perspective”, Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 48 (9), pp. 1804-1828.
Thirlwall A. (2011), “Balance of payments constrained growth models: history and overview”, PSL Quarterly Review, 64(259), pp. 307-351.
Tooze A. (2018), Crashed: How a Decade of Financial Crises Changed the World, New York: Viking Publishing.
Van Doorslaer H. and Vermeiren M. (2021), “Pushing on a String: Monetary Policy, Growth Models and the Persistence of Low Inflation in Advanced Capitalism”, New Political Economy, 26(5), pp. 797-816.
Vermeiren M. (2014), Power and imbalances in the global monetary system A comparative capitalism perspective, Berlin: Springer.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Andrea Carrera, Luís Cárdenas, Víctor Arribas Martínez
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
