The European Banking Union: Will It Be a True Union without Risk Sharing?


  • Mario Sarcinelli



banking union, eurozone, crisis


The recent developments of the Euro crisis reveal the lack of clear or coherent thinking on the part of both the Eurozone finance ministers and the European Commission. The crisis in Cyprus is partly the consequence of decisions made on private sector involvement in the previous Greek bailout, and other such examples may be made. It is time, therefore, to look reality in the face and strengthen the structures of the EMU. The article is devoted to what has been done and what must still be done to make the European banking system more robust and less permeable to crises, and to preserve the single financial market. It looks at the initiatives of both the European Commission and the European Council to complete the EMU by creating a banking union, the doubts on the wisdom of entrusting banking oversight to the ECB, the organization of the ECB’s new tasks, the continuing absence of facilities for the recovery or liquidation of banks, as well as for a Euro-wide deposit insurance, the need for some form of risk-sharing in order to stabilise the economy, and thus the recourse to a common budget and the possibility of joint debt for the Eurozone. 



JEL Codes: G01, G28, G18


ADVISORY SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE (2012), "Forbearance, Resolution and Deposit Insurance", Report of the ASC, n. 1, European Systemic Risk Board, July, Frankfurt.

ALESSANDRINI P., FRATIANNI M., HUGHES HALLETT A. and PRESBITERO A.F. (2012), "External Imbalances and Financial Fragility in the Euro Area", Mo.Fi.R. Working Papers, n. 66, Università Politecnica delle Marche.

ALLEN F., BECK T., CARLETTI E., LANE P., SCHOENMAKER D. and WAGNER W. (2011), "Cross-Border Banking in Europe: Implications for Financial Stability and Macroeconomic Policies", CEPR Report, London.

BAYOUMI T. and EICHENGREEN B. (1999), "Operationalising the Theory of Optimum Currency Areas", in Baldwin R., Cohen D., Sapir A. and Venables A. (eds.), Market Integration, Regionalism and the Global Economy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

BERNARDI E. (2012), "Unione bancaria, gestione delle crisi e protezione dei depositanti", Bancaria, vol. 68 n. 12, pp. 46-53.

BINI SMAGHI L. (2008), Il paradosso dell'euro: luci ed ombre dieci anni dopo, Milan: Rizzoli.

BOYER C.P. and PONCE J. (2010), "Central Banks, Regulatory Capture and Banking Supervisory Reform", Paolo Baffi Centre Research Paper, n. 2010-83.

BRUTON J. (2013), "Cyprus… A Test Case for Future European Banking Policy", CEPS Commentary, 21 March.

CESARATTO S. (2012), "Controversial and Novel Features of the Eurozone Crisis as a Balance of Payments Crisis", Quaderni del Dipartimento di Economia e Statistica, n. 640, University of Siena.

DARVAS Z. and WOLFF G.B. (2013), "It Is not yet too Late to Drop the Idea of Capital Controls in Cyprus", Bruegel Blog, 27 March.

DARVAS Z. and WOLFF G.B. (2013) "Should Non-Euro Area Countries Join the Single Supervisory Mechanism?", Bruegel Policy Contribution, n. 6, 13 March.

DE GRAUWE P. (2011), "Managing a Fragile Eurozone", CESifo Forum, n. 2, pp. 40-45.

DE GRAUWE P. and JI Y. (2013), "More Evidence that Financial Markets Imposed Excessive Austerity in the Eurozone", CEPS Commentary, 5 February.

DE GRAUWE P. and JI Y. (2012), "Self-Fulfilling Crises in the Eurozone. An Empirical Test", Journal of International Money and Finance, vol. 34, pp. 15-36.

DE GRAUWE P. and MOESEN W. (2009), "Gains for All: A Proposal for a Common Euro Bond", Intereconomics, May/June, pp. 131-135.

DE LAROSIÈRE J. (ed.) (2009), Report of the High Level Group on Financial Supervision in the EU, Brussels, 25 February.

DELPLA J. and VON WEIZSÄCKER J. (2010), "The Blue Bond Proposal", Bruegel Policy Brief, n. 2010/03, Bruegel.

DE SCHOUTHEETE P. and MICOSSI S. (2013), "On Political Union in Europe: The Changing Landscape of Decision-Making and Political Accountability", CEPS Essay, n. 4, 21 February.

DULLIEN S. (2012), "Why the Euro Crisis Threatens the European Single Market", Policy Memo, n. 64, European Council on Foreign Relations.

DYSON K. and FEATHERSTONE D. (1999), A Road to Maastricht – Negotiating Economic and Monetary Union, Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.

EMERSON M., GROS D., ITALIANER A., PISANI-FERRY J. and REICHENBACH H. (1990), One Market, One Money, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

ENDERLEIN H. (ed.) (2012), Completing the Euro – A Road Map towards Fiscal Union in Europe, Report of the "Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa Group", Notre Europe, n. 92, June.

EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK (2012), Opinion on a Proposal for a Directive Establishing a Framework for Recovery and Resolution of Credit Institutions and Investment Firms (CON/2012/99), 29 November.

EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK (2012), Financial Stability Review, June.

EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK (2001), The Role of Central Banks in Prudential Supervision.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION (2012), A Roadmap towards a Banking Union, Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council, COM(2012) 510 final, 12 September, Brussels.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION (2012), Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council Establishing a Framework for the Recovery and Resolution of Credit Institutions and Investment Firms, COM/(2012)/0280 final, Brussels, 6 June.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION (2012), A Blueprint for a Deep and Genuine EMU – Launching a European Debate, COM(2012) 777 final/2, Brussels, 30 November.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION (2010), Proposal for a Directive.../.../EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on Deposit Guarantee Schemes [recast], COM(2010) 369, Brussels, 12 July.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION – DIRECTORATE GENERAL FOR ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL AFFAIRS (2008), "EMU@10: Successes and Challenges after 10 Years of Economic and Monetary Union", European Economy, n. 2.

EUROPEAN COUNCIL (2012), Conclusions (28/29 June 2012), EUCO 76/12, Brussels.

EUROPEAN COUNCIL (2012), Conclusions (18/19 October 2012), EUCO 156/12, Brussels.

EUROPEAN COUNCIL (2012), Conclusions (13/14 December 2012), EUCO 205/12, Brussels.

FRANKEL J.A. and ROSE A.K. (1998), "The Endogeneity of the Optimum Currency Area Criteria", Economic Journal, vol. 108 n. 449, pp. 1009-1025.

FRANKEL J.A. and ROSE A.K. (1997), The Endogeneity of the Optimum Currency Area Criteria, revised draft September 24.

GERHARDT M. and LANNOO K (2011), "Options for Reforming Deposit Protection in the EU", ECRI Policy Brief, n. 4, European Credit Research Institute, Brussels.

GIRAUD G. (2013), "Un projet de réforme bancaire insatisfaisant", Le Monde, 14 February.

GROS D. (2013), "Banking Union with a Sovereign Virus: The Self-Serving Regulatory Treatment of Sovereign Debt in the Euro Area", CEPS Policy Brief, n. 289, 27 March.

HENNING C.R. and KESSLER M. (2012), "Fiscal Federalism: US History for Architects of Europe's Fiscal Union", Bruegel Essay and Lecture Series, 10 January.

IMF STAFF (2013), "A Banking Union for the Euro Area", Discussion Note, SDN/13/01, International Monetary Fund, Washington (DC).

INDEPENDENT COMMISSION ON BANKING (2011), Final Report, London, September 12.

JONUNG L. and DREA E. (2009), "The Euro: It Can't Happen, It's a Bad Idea, It Won't Last. US Economists on the EMU, 1989-2002", presented at the ASSA meetings, San Francisco, January 3.

KENEN P.B. (2002), "Currency Unions and Policy Domains", in Andrews D.M., Henning C.R. and Pauly L.W. (eds.), Governing the World's Money, Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, pp. 78-104.

KENEN P.B. (1969), "The Theory of Optimum Currency Areas: An Eclectic View", in Mundell R.A. and Swoboda A.K. (eds.), Monetary Problems of the International Economy, Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 41-60.

KRUGMAN P. (1993), "Lessons of Massachusetts for EMU", in Giavazzi F. and Torres F. (eds.), Adjustment and Growth in the European Monetary Union, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

LIIKANEN E. (ed.) (2012), Final Report of the High-Level Expert Group on Reforming the Structure of the EU Banking Sector, Brussels, 2 October.

MARÈ M. and SARCINELLI M. (1998), Europa: cosa ci attende? L'Unione Europea tra mercato e istituzioni, Rome and Bari: Laterza.

MCKINNON R.I. (1963), "Optimum Currency Areas", American Economic Review, vol. 53, pp. 717-725.

MEADE J. (1957), "The Balance-of-Payments Problems of a European Free-Trade Area", The Economic Journal, vol. 67 n. 267, pp. 379-396.

MUNDELL R.A. (1961), "The Theory of Optimum Currency Areas", American Economic Review, vol. 51, pp. 509-517.

OATES W. (1968), "The Theory of Public Finance in a Federal System", Canadian Journal of Economics, vol. 1 n. 1, pp. 37-54.

PADOA-SCHIOPPA T. (2007), "Europe Needs a Single Financial Rule Book", Financial Times, December 10.

PADOA-SCHIOPPA T. (ed.) (1987), Efficiency, Stability and Equity: A Strategy for the Evolution of the Economic System of the European Community, Report of a study group appointed by the Commission of the European Communities.

PISANI-FERRY J. (2012), "The Known Unknowns and Unknown Unknowns of EMU", Bruegel Policy Contribution, n. 18, October.

PISANI-FERRY J, VIHRIÄLÄ E. and WOLFF G. (2013), "Options for a Euro-Area Fiscal Capacity", Bruegel Policy Contribution, n. 1, January.

PRODI R. and QUADRIO CURZIO A. (2011), "EuroUnionBond per la nuova Europa", Il Sole-24 Ore, 23 August.

RUDING H.O. (2012), "The Contents and Timing of a European Banking Union: Reflections on the Differing Views", CEPS Essay, Brussels, 30 November.

SARCINELLI M. (2013) "L'unione bancaria europea e la stabilizzazione dell'Eurozona", Moneta e Credito, vol. 66 n. 261, pp. 7-42.

SARCINELLI M. (2013) "Perché l'Unione bancaria europea?", Economia italiana, n. 2013/1, pp. 25-32.

SARCINELLI M. (2012), "Come difendere la globalizzazione e salvaguardare i sistemi bancari dal contagio?", Moneta e Credito, vol. 65 n. 257, pp. 9-47.

SARCINELLI M. (2012), "Euro Crisis or Public Debt Crisis? With a Remedy for the Latter Case", PSL Quarterly Review, vol. 65 n. 262, pp. 215-236.

SARCINELLI M. (2010) "'Europa 2020', nuovo governo economico e ri-regolamentazione finanziaria: incentivi o vincoli alla crescita?", Moneta e Credito, vol. 63 n. 252, pp. 291-324.

SARCINELLI M. (2009), "UEM ed Euro: i successi del passato e le sfide del futuro", Studi sull'integrazione europea, vol. IV n. 2, pp. 341-359.

SARCINELLI M. (2004), La vigilanza sul sistema finanziario: una, nessuna o centomila? "Lectio doctoralis" at the Università degli Studi di Bari, School of Economics, Bari, 4 June; published in (2004), Notiziario della Banca Popolare di Sondrio, n. 95, pp. 37-41; republished (2004), Bancaria, September, n. 9, pp. 2-8.

SARCINELLI M. (2004), La vigilanza sul sistema finanziario: una, nessuna o centomila?, Notiziario della Banca Popolare di Sondrio, n. 95, pp. 37-41.

SARCINELLI M. (2004), La vigilanza sul sistema finanziario: una, nessuna o centomila?, Bancaria, September, n. 9, pp. 2-8.

SARCINELLI M. (2003), "Politica monetaria e politica fiscale in Europa: strade divergenti per sempre?", in Federazione Nazionale dei Cavalieri del Lavoro (ed.), L'Europa possibile, Atti del convegno, 28-29 marzo, Naples: Avagliano, pp. 39-68.

SARCINELLI M. (2002), "L'organizzazione e la distribuzione dei compiti tra le autorità nazionali e quelle europee per la vigilanza bancaria e finanziaria", Rivista Bancaria-Minerva Bancaria, n. 5, pp. 11-27.

SARCINELLI M. (1992), "La banca centrale europea: istituzione concettualmente 'evoluta' o all'inizio della sua 'evoluzione'?", Moneta e Credito, n. 178, pp. 143-170.

SCHOENMAKER D. (2013), Governance of International Banking: The Financial Trilemma, Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.

SCHOENMAKER D. and GROS D. (2012), "A European Deposit Insurance and Resolution Fund: An Update", DSF Policy Paper Series, n. 26, September.

SWEET W.J. and CHRISTIANSEN B.D. (2011), "The Volcker Rule", Skadden Newsletter.

VAN ROMPUY H.A. (2012), Towards a Genuine Economic and Monetary Union – Report, EUCO 120/12, Brussels, 26 June.

VAN ROMPUY H.A. (2012), Towards a Genuine Economic and Monetary Union – Interim Report, Brussels, 12 October.

VAN ROMPUY H.A. (2012), Towards a Genuine Economic and Monetary Union – Final Report, Brussels, 5 December.

VICKERS J. (2012), "Some Economics of Banking Reform", Rivista di Politica Economica, n. X-XII, pp. 11-35.

WALTERS A.A. (1990), Sterling in Danger: Economic Consequences of Fixed Exchange Rates, London: Fontana Press/Collins.

WOLFF G.B. (2012), "A Budget for Europe's Monetary Union", Bruegel Policy Contribution, n. 22, December.


How to Cite

Sarcinelli, M. (2013). The European Banking Union: Will It Be a True Union without Risk Sharing?. PSL Quarterly Review, 66(265).