Implementation of the BIS “rules” on capital adequacy assessment. A comparative study of the approaches adopted in the UK, the USA and Japan


  • M.J.B. HALL



Financial regulation, capital adequacy


In 1987, the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Basle Supervisor's Committee agreed on a methodology for the evaluation of capital adequacy with respect to internationally active banks in December 1987. This code has since been accepted by many countries, although the approaches followed in its implementation have been different. This article looks at implementation in the United Kingdom, the United States and Japan. The author seeks to identify competitive distortions, using detailed tables.


JEL: G18


BANK FOR INTERNATIONAL SETTLEMENTs (BIS), Proposals for international convergence 01

capital measurement and capital standards, Consultative paper issued by the Committee

on Banking Regulations and Supervisory Praetiees (tbe Basle Committee),

(Basle, Deeember, 1987).

BIS, Proposals for the inclusion of general provisionslgeneral loan loss reserves in capita l,

Consultative paper issued by the Basle Committee (BasIe, February 1991).

BANK OF ENGLAND, Subordinated Loan Capitai Issued by Recognised Banks and Licensed

Deposit-'akers (BSDI1986/2), Moceh 1986.

BANK OF ENGLAND, Implementatian of the Basle Convergence Agreement in the United

Kingdom (BSDI1988/3), Oetober 1988.

BANK OF ENGLAND, Implementatian in the United Kingdom 01 tbe Directive on Own Funds

Credit Institutions (BSD/199012), December 1990a.

BANK OF ENGLAND, Implementation in the United Kingdom of tbe Solvency Ratio Directive

(BSD/1990/3), Deeember 1990b.

DALE, R, "Japan's Banking Regulation: Current Poliey Issues", in fapanese Financial

Growth, by Goodbart, C.AB. and Sutija, G. (eds.), Maemillan, 1990, pp. 33-45.

EC, Directive on the Annual Accounts and Consolidated Accounts o/ Banks and Other

Financial Institutions ("Bank Accounts Directive") (86/635/EEC), 8 December 1986

EC, Directive on the Own Funds of Credi! Institutions ("Own Funds Directive")

(89/299/EEC), 17 April 1989.

EC, Directive on the Solvency Ratia for Credit Institutions ("Solvency Ratio Directive")

(89/647/EEC), 18 Deeember 1989.

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM, Capital Adequacy Guidelines, Board of Governors, March 1986

HALL. M.J.B., "Tbe BIS CapitaI Adequacy 'Rules', A Critique", in this Review, no. 169,

June 1989, pp. 207-227.

HALL, M.J.B., "Commeot" 00 Dale's paper in ]apanese Financial Growth) Macmillan,

, pp. 46-51.

HALL, M.J.B., "The Bank for International Settlements' CapitaI Adequacy 'Rules':

Implications for Banks Operating in the UK", Service lndustries Journal, Volume 10,

No.1, January 1990b, pp. 147-71.

JAPANESE MINIS'fRY QF FINANCE, Outli~e 0j the ,Ollieial Notification Concerning th~

Implementation 01 the Baste Commzttee s CapIta! Adequacy Framework) Decembet

OF THRIFT SUPERVISION, Regulatory Capital: Interest Rate Risk Component, July




How to Cite

HALL, M. (2013). Implementation of the BIS “rules” on capital adequacy assessment. A comparative study of the approaches adopted in the UK, the USA and Japan. PSL Quarterly Review, 45(180).